2025 NM Elk Draw Thread

I was a resident back in 93-96 and drew archery elk tags every year. Military moved me away. Many years later I applied with a buddy attached to my application and we drew first year. The next year he applied and I attached to his application...we drew. Haven't drawn since. All applications have been through outfitter pool to have better odds. E-plus has been our route until we draw again.
 
I usually go guided because of the crazy demands at work plus I usually go by myself and it helps with the pack out process if you've ever packed an bull elk out you appreciate all the help you can get and I've done it alone twice - I love elk meat, and I want it ALL plus getting it taken care of quickly is important me it's the reason why I hunt with that being said I did put in for the New Mexico draw with the outfitters preference and was unsuccessful which I had my fingers crossed but really didn't have any hope. Big Antlers of course are really cool and buying a landowner tag that isn't at the top of the price range and going to a Unit that has high expectations of realistically killing a 330" bull with a rifle is awesome, I'm sold, sign me up - Oh and did I say that I'm getting help with all the meat care lol !!

Going on an awesome landowner tag with an awesome outfitter and it's not that expensive.

Hopefully posting pics and the hunt story when I get back - I'm going Oct. first rifle.
 
I was a resident back in 93-96 and drew archery elk tags every year. Military moved me away. Many years later I applied with a buddy attached to my application and we drew first year. The next year he applied and I attached to his application...we drew. Haven't drawn since. All applications have been through outfitter pool to have better odds. E-plus has been our route until we draw again.
Yeah, I was a resident the first time in high school from 1989-1992 we had 1 elk tag between my dad and me for 3 years of applications. So you got lucky.
 
Congratulations on drawing.

Please put your story and pics on here when you get back that would be awesome.

DM me I'd like to hear more rifle, bow, plan etc.
I drew a December either sex muzzleloader tag. Pretty excited about it this will be my first late season hunt so I’m getting all my new gear for the hunt. Going in with the mindset of just take the first opportunity presented cow or bull.
 
I usually go guided because of the crazy demands at work plus I usually go by myself and it helps with the pack out process if you've ever packed an bull elk out you appreciate all the help you can get and I've done it alone twice - I love elk meat, and I want it ALL plus getting it taken care of quickly is important me it's the reason why I hunt with that being said I did put in for the New Mexico draw with the outfitters preference and was unsuccessful which I had my fingers crossed but really didn't have any hope. Big Antlers of course are really cool and buying a landowner tag that isn't at the top of the price range and going to a Unit that has high expectations of realistically killing a 330" bull with a rifle is awesome, I'm sold, sign me up - Oh and did I say that I'm getting help with all the meat care lol !!

Going on an awesome landowner tag with an awesome outfitter and it's not that expensive.

Hopefully posting pics and the hunt story when I get back - I'm going Oct. first rifle.
The GMUs that have a higher number of E-Plus unit wide land owner tags have a much lower trophy potential these days. There are some private land only hunts that still have decent trophy potential depending on the size and location of the ranch. The Tribes have rifle hunts during the rut but very few tags available and are very expensive. For a 330 bull or better I would say there are better chances in some GMUs but I wouldn’t have any expectations.
 
The GMUs that have a higher number of E-Plus unit wide land owner tags have a much lower trophy potential these days. There are some private land only hunts that still have decent trophy potential depending on the size and location of the ranch. The Tribes have rifle hunts during the rut but very few tags available and are very expensive. For a 330 bull or better I would say there are better chances in some GMUs but I wouldn’t have any expectations.
So in your experience the eplus system has diminished the quality of the herd across the board?
 
Drew 36 muzzy elk this year!! Dumb luck
Hopefully you find a big one. I hunted that with rifle last year. Didn’t see the quality I was hoping for but did see one nice 330” bull. Ended up taking a 300”. Let me know if you want to connect about it.
 
So in your experience the eplus system has diminished the quality of the herd across the board?
Yes, but not in every unit. In those GMUs that have a high number of Unit Wide LO tags (E-Plus) the trophy potential as well as the success rates have suffered. However this does not apply to some Lincoln NF units like unit 34. In GMU 34 DGF hands out more tags than they normally would in an effort to reduce the elk herd population because of CWD. I am not very familiar with the Northern units.

I suspect from being on a couple of those UW hunts, that many of these bulls are taken on public land. But the harvest reports didn’t ask if the bull was taken on private or public land. The DGF should be taking that data because it drives how many tags are to be allocated to the public draw as well as private land tags. I do know that some of these large e-plus ranches lock out the public where elk enter private land.

The DGF sells “quality hunts” (Q) in the public draw that are supposed to be limited access which increases the cost of the tag and reduces the odds of being drawn. Yet, if there are just as many E-Plus tags as there are tags in the public draw, double the number of hunters out there for at least the first rifle hunt. In some units I suspect that the bull to cow ratios have become lower, even to the point that the elk populations have become lower. I say that because the survey data I have seen so far is devoid of any impacts from e-plus as well as wolf depredation.
 
I'm not sure about other units...but unit 52 has about 37 unit wide Eplus archery tags available. They issue 230 tags total for Res, Non res and outfitter combined for each season....(meaning 460 for early and late). so I'd say unit 52 isn't getting affected much by Eplus tags in the archery segment. There are 51 total unit wide MB tags for Muzzy, and all rifle seasons available. Again...I think that is 230 per each season for rifle and like 180 for muzzle loader(I may be wrong)....but to think that that particular unit is being run through by non res hunters is a bit of a stretch.
 
I'm not sure about other units...but unit 52 has about 37 unit wide Eplus archery tags available. They issue 230 tags total for Res, Non res and outfitter combined for each season....(meaning 460 for early and late). so I'd say unit 52 isn't getting affected much by Eplus tags in the archery segment. There are 51 total unit wide MB tags for Muzzy, and all rifle seasons available. Again...I think that is 230 per each season for rifle and like 180 for muzzle loader(I may be wrong)....but to think that that particular unit is being run through by non res hunters is a bit of a stretch.

You would be shocked at how many elk are actually being pulled out of 52. I bet more elk are killed out of season in that unit than during a season. In a week I saw 9 elk in trucks with no elk season open. Game and fish said they were 3 days out from being able to get there.
 
I'm not sure about other units...but unit 52 has about 37 unit wide Eplus archery tags available. They issue 230 tags total for Res, Non res and outfitter combined for each season....(meaning 460 for early and late). so I'd say unit 52 isn't getting affected much by Eplus tags in the archery segment. There are 51 total unit wide MB tags for Muzzy, and all rifle seasons available. Again...I think that is 230 per each season for rifle and like 180 for muzzle loader(I may be wrong)....but to think that that particular unit is being run through by non res hunters is a bit of a stretch.
Archery E-plus UW Land Owner tags don’t usually have much impact on a GMU because of the difficulty and fewer tags available. In 2022 there were 100 unit wide mature bull tags for GMU 51. There were about 200 mature bull tags in the public draw for first rifle. 16% of those public draw tags went to non-residents. Like I said before, the ranches with Unit Wide tags have their own outfitters or contract out to an outfitter. Residents are not sold the Unit Wide LO tags. All of those tags get rolled into booked hunts for non-residents. Very few Residents are able to buy those e-plus UW LO tags.

Most clients want to hunt first rifle so that means there are 50% more hunters hunting public ground competing with the public draw hunters. Most of those bulls are taken on federal and state lands. So what happens? In quite a few GMUs the bulls are over hunted and the trophy quality nose-dives. And of course then success rates plummet. There are some units, actually one Gila unit, where there are just as many bull Unit Wide Landowner tags that there are the total number of public draw tags for the first rifle hunt. For the math challenged that means there are twice as many hunters out there on public lands for the first rifle season.
 
I see your point...but also...there are elk that come in and out of 51 depending on migrating and such. Not sure if season dates would have an effect on that...51 hasn't been known as a trophy unit ever as I've known it (since 94). Just try and keep the heard down is what NMGF is trying to do there. Last year there were 107 Eplus rifle/muzzle loader tags. If there are 10 outfitters in the unit...I find it hard to believe that all 10 outfitters would book 10 hunters for the early hunt...they also have dudes that actually drew through the pool. I understand that most guides usually split each season....but to say that all 107 tags are during first rifle is hard for me to comprehend.
 
I see your point...but also...there are elk that come in and out of 51 depending on migrating and such. Not sure if season dates would have an effect on that...51 hasn't been known as a trophy unit ever as I've known it (since 94). Just try and keep the heard down is what NMGF is trying to do there. Last year there were 107 Eplus rifle/muzzle loader tags. If there are 10 outfitters in the unit...I find it hard to believe that all 10 outfitters would book 10 hunters for the early hunt...they also have dudes that actually drew through the pool. I understand that most guides usually split each season....but to say that all 107 tags are during first rifle is hard for me to comprehend.
The e-plus UW mature bull tags are for any season and any weapon type the authorization holder chooses. Obviously there are archery only tags. Sometimes the authorizations are sold two or three times between outfitters depending on the hunts they can book. Most clients want the first or early rifle or early muzzle hunt if they have a choice. In 2024 GMU 52 early rifle hunt had 11% draw odds for residents with a 33% success rate which is dismal. If an outfitter is fully booked they will sell the authorizations to other outfitters.

Used to be that outfitters had their own stomping grounds which is still true to a certain degree today, but they will go where the tag is. When I do my pre-season boots on the ground scouting I might run into guides from two or three outfitters looking in the same area. There are true trophy units with few E-Plus tags that have the same draw odds of about 10% (residents) with twice the success rate.
 
Archery E-plus UW Land Owner tags don’t usually have much impact on a GMU because of the difficulty and fewer tags available. In 2022 there were 100 unit wide mature bull tags for GMU 51. There were about 200 mature bull tags in the public draw for first rifle. 16% of those public draw tags went to non-residents. Like I said before, the ranches with Unit Wide tags have their own outfitters or contract out to an outfitter. Residents are not sold the Unit Wide LO tags. All of those tags get rolled into booked hunts for non-residents. Very few Residents are able to buy those e-plus UW LO tags.

Most clients want to hunt first rifle so that means there are 50% more hunters hunting public ground competing with the public draw hunters. Most of those bulls are taken on federal and state lands. So what happens? In quite a few GMUs the bulls are over hunted and the trophy quality nose-dives. And of course then success rates plummet. There are some units, actually one Gila unit, where there are just as many bull Unit Wide Landowner tags that there are the total number of public draw tags for the first rifle hunt. For the math challenged that means there are twice as many hunters out there on public lands for the first rifle season.
Seems kind of dumb that DGF doesnt regulate which season for eplus unit wide. Would make sense to me to allocate which season they can be used on. Like no crap all those guys are hammering first rifle. I don't know the stats but I would assume success in 1st rifle is about 5x archery success. Would seem they could give the landowners more tags and specify them as archery. Would surely generate more revenue for the landowner. Although as an archery hunter that would be less than ideal for my hunt.
 
You'd also think that most Eplus archery tags are used in the second season....And it could be...but the success rates are normally higher in first season or equal.
 
You'd also think that most Eplus archery tags are used in the second season....And it could be...but the success rates are normally higher in first season or equal.
In some units there are few archery UW tags given to land owners (outfitters)…But down here in the Southern units the peak rut rut doesn’t kick in until until the middle of September and lasts through the middle of October. 2nd archery always has a higher success rate unless something major happens like a fire. But if there are 200 tags in the public draw and there are only say like 30 E-plus guided hunts there won’t be an obvious change in success rate. But the outfitters will use those UW tags during the 2nd season you can bet on it!
 
in the past few years...the rut hasn't kicked in until late sept/early oct in the northern units either. 2 years ago bulls where still grouped up 12 sept. This is in northern unit. Last year...some bull groups had split up...but my buddy killed his bull amongst a group of bulls bachelor up. that was on 8 Sep. I was on bugling bulls that were broken up 4 miles the opposite direction. same unit.
 
Back
Top