I think a Go-No Go gauge is typically around a 6-thousandths difference, and your smith went 7-Ten-Thousandths deeper in the chamber, so I wouldn't think that would make any difference in your bolt closing.good to know. Too bad they're letting vendors keep this product on the shelf. I have 3 different lot numbers all purchased over the last 3 months. Every lot is doing this.
Could the carbon ring have been the black Sharpie scratched off the bullet?
Did you try any other manufacturer's ammo in the chamber?
Hornady does offer a warranty. I would contact them and see what they say.