I really appreciate all the replies. I've been digging around deeper in the scope eval threads and have really learned a lot there as well. I have to admit, I appreciate the logic in the following quote in the Credo 3-9x40 Q&A threads as far as comparing to the SWFA 3-9x:
And this:
So here is where I am now
1) SWFA SS HD 3-9x42 - Top choice right now...but backorder only
2) Zeiss Conquest V4 3-10x44 - eliminated
3) Burris Fullfield E1 3-9x40 - would love to see a drop test on this one as it seems popular on rokslide...but can't imagine it would pass. Eliminated.
4) Burris...
Looked harder at the Credo. From the looks on the website and several reviews, I think I like the reticle on the SWFA better. The SWFA reticle just looks like it would work out better for my uses.
I actually looked at the Swaro Z3 when I first started looking...based on swaro reputation. I have since read some things about this particular model (Z3) that leads me to believe it may not be appropriate for a muzzleloader. Reliability/ability to take recoil is my number one consideration here.
So would the Zeiss Conquest V4 also be considered middle of the road glass nowadays? I have an older Zeiss Conquest 4.5-14x44 and I consider that glass excellent...but I do not have a $2000+ scope to compare it to either.
That is the one I am leaning towards now. I don't think I really need to dial for my use, but I do like that this scope has passed impact tests well. The only thing I am not sure of is the glass on the SWFA. I've never seen one...didn't even know about one until a few weeks ago. How would it...
I did read those. Main reason I kicked out the Leupold. I did not see any tests for the Zeiss and Burris I listed.
You listed the Credo HX and not the regular Credo as a possibility. Any reason why? I see they have a 3-9x40 in the standard Credo.
I have found myself in need of a new scope. I haven't purchased or researched scopes in about 15 years, and the scope I need to replace is over 20 years old. My has the market changed. I need some help/recommendations as I am not familiar with a lot of what is offered today. The scope I am...
Saying hello! I've recently come into the market for a scope and search engines led me to this forum. I've learned a lot already from Form's scope reviews. Joined to post a few questions I had.