He is "We shoot bucks like that where I come from" inches. 4 point with brow tines. Unless one has had opportunity to take quite a few large mule deer, don't see why one would pass it unless you are in a legitimate trophy unit/season.
What Marine4life said, muzzleloader. Way fun to hunt with. Most folks who get into muzzleloading soon realize it's fun, challenging, and the different season dates vs. rifle are pretty cool.
What cnelk said. Also, during the rut, bulls run cows, and aren't in bachelor groups. Focus on learning the whole unit, eliminate the "no way elk will be here" areas, access, trails, etc. Try to get in a few days before opener, really look for elk then (will be a lot different).
Something that I always bring: electrical tape. Works great if one has a cut to seal it up, apply pressure. Tape tags on after a kill. Fix boots, makeshift belt, etc.
If you hunt before they shed velvet (varies, but sometime around 7th or so of September, sometimes sooner), find the most open, not thick areas you can. They don't like to injure the velvet. If after they shed, then focus on limiting factors. Water, food, cover, etc. If nothing is really...
Technology levels the playing field. Rookie hunters/fisherman can "catch up" to more experienced folks quickly with technology aids. So, instead of the same handful of people catching/killing most of the overall take, it is a broader population. Is that bad? I don't think so. However, the...
1) would I be better off hiring a guide or outfitter or does this unit lend itself to DIY.
If this is your first mule deer hunt, I would suggest an outfitter. Idaho mule deer hunting can be tough, regardless of the tag and/or unit. Thick country, steep, game isn't found everywhere, and the...
Agreed, match vs. hunting is a horse that has met a 1000 deaths. Personal experience using various bullets, watching others use various bullets and with most calibers one can think of: Shot placement is the single biggest influence regarding bloodshot meat.
Example: Way back in the 1900's...
Sounds like you have gone through everything. If it were mine, it would be gone. I don't have the patience for a finicky rifle anymore. I am sure you could sort out a load eventually, do you really want to? Will you trust the rifle? Things to think about.
What Mountainrancher said. 6.5 is plenty for elk or mule deer, I can confirm with personal experience.
Being able to seal the deal when an opportunity presents itself has nothing to do with the caliber.
Do I always de-bone? No, depends. Loose meat can be a challenge to keep still in a pack sometimes. I rarely de-bone hinds (I like bone in roasts, improves flavor IMO), fronts I will as the bone is a much larger percentage of the weight.
Leap frog? Not often, but if it is stupid steep out or...
I hear ya. This is a newer version my winter bag, mine is about 3 years old now. No complaints, never been cold. https://www.marmot.com/equipment/sleeping-bags/down-bags/mens-col--20-sleeping-bag---long/AFS_195115053000.html
Depending on the unit, it could be below zero. Hunted 4th season in the Gunnison area a few years back, most mornings were minus 5 to minus 10 when we were heading out. We had a propane heater in the wall tent, regulator kept freezing up kind of cold.
IDFG closed the investigation in the grizz killing. No citation issued. https://idfg.idaho.gov/article/fg-concludes-investigation-panhandle-region-grizzly-bear-shooting