Western Rookie Rifle Advice

MTlan66

FNG
Joined
Aug 12, 2025
Messages
4
This is my first post on here. I hope it’s not too redundant, as somewhat similar questions have been asked, but I have recently moved to the west, and would like some advice and opinions on rifle and set up.
For background, I’ve been hunting for 30 years or so, almost entirely whitetails, quite a bit in Texas, a few in Oklahoma and Arkansas, but mostly in Virginia. My only practical rifle that I currently own is a T/C Compass (first generation) chambered in 6.5 Creedmoor. It is currently wearing a Vortex Diamondback HP 4-16 x 42 scope, mounted in Weaver rings on the stock dovetail bases. The only modifications to the gun itself, is an Mcarbo trigger spring and an aftermarket oversized bolt handle. Oh, and the sponge paint job on the stock by yours truly!
I am quite comfortable with this rifle, having shot it nearly exclusively for the past six years. I’ve shot one coyote and one turkey, both around the 300 yard mark, countless deer at ranges from 15 to 440 yards, and 2 late season cow elk in Montana at 359 and 409 yards respectively. Going forward with the prospect of hunting antelope, mule deer and elk around my home on a consistent basis, I find myself in a delightful rifle dilemma, that I welcome any comments or opinions on! I should probably mention that I have a wife and five kids, and the hunting budget is fairly thin.
These are the options I am considering:

1. Continue to use this rifle as is, and never think another thing about it. This is probably the wisest choice, but extremely boring!

2. Start saving money in minds of buying a high-end rifle somewhere down the road, when experience will have taught me what I think I truly need

3. Dump money into my current gun. In some ways, this is the most appealing option to me. Perhaps upgrade scope and mounting system. I do not like the flimsy, plastic stock, and I thought about putting an MDT Oryx chassis on it. Really the only other option I’ve come across for an aftermarket stock is a Boyds, and for reasons I can’t totally explain, that does not really appeal to me.

I really do like this rifle, and it has never let me down. It’s far more accurate than I can shoot, and has the three position safety very similar to the Winchester model 70’s that I first started hunting with when I was a teenager. Everything about action and barrel feels real solid, I just have the question if a cheap gun like this is worth investing more money in.

A suppressor is on the short list, regardless what route I take.

I apologize for the length of this post. Any thoughts and opinions are very welcome. Thank you!
 
Keep using what you have, but also start planning on something fun and aspirational. A semi-custom Tikka has been extremely fun for me to build this past six months. I finally managed to shoot it a few times this past weekend and the initial results are very promising.

fdead2c13e6ff5309554868846f0e933.jpg


*I* would not sink another dime into what you have, but I would start getting a truly reliable scope, suppressor, mounts, etc. that can go on your dream rifle. The rifle you have clearly works for you, but in itself I don’t see how you can put more money into the rifle itself that won’t be better spent elsewhere.


____________________
“Keep on keepin’ on…”
 
It is currently wearing a Vortex Diamondback HP 4-16 x 42 scope

You have a solid list of potential options and understanding of how they could help you it sounds like... but 100% absolutely get a reliable optic as your first move. Look at the Vortex drop test section done on here- none of them pass. Dozens of independent threads across the internet will confirm this. At east coast whitetail hunting differences, you may not notice a loss of zero, but you don't want to plan/ train for an elk tag for two years and miss because your scope is off.

It intuitively seems kind of silly spending twice as much on your optic as you did on your rifle, but with manufacturing technology these days a rifle like yours wearing something like a Trijicon Huron would be a great little setup.
 
1. Continue to use this rifle as is, and never think another thing about it. This is probably the wisest choice, but extremely boring!

Might upgrade the glass and mounts but otherwise leave it alone

2. Start saving money in minds of buying a high-end rifle somewhere down the road, when experience will have taught me what I think I truly need

Yes.

3. Dump money into my current gun. In some ways, this is the most appealing option to me. Perhaps upgrade scope and mounting system. I do not like the flimsy, plastic stock, and I thought about putting an MDT Oryx chassis on it. Really the only other option I’ve come across for an aftermarket stock is a Boyds, and for reasons I can’t totally explain, that does not really appeal to me.

NO!!!!!!!! Its a cheap gun. Dump all the money want into a cheap gun and it will still be a cheap gun..Dont go down that rabbit hole.

Though a guy can do some improvements to the stock with a die grinder and some 2 part epoxy
Upgrade the glass and leave it alone

I just have the question if a cheap gun like this is worth investing more money in.

No
 
Do your own drop test and tracking/tall target tests. If it passes, think about other options. If not, put a reliable scope and mount on top and go from there.
 
I agree with others - get a stock you like and upgrade the scope. However, many of us own multiple rifles of all sorts.

If you were to add a 22-250, 22 creed or 204 Ruger for plinking/varmints it would get used quite a bit out west. A 17 HMR is also fantastic and much more accurate than a 22lr, but also get an accurate 22 lr. A 22 pistol is always fun to plink with while out and about or camping. I always have a 243 loaner rifle for anyone that needs it, that I also shoot the heck out of.

It’s a great time to keep an eye out for any cartridge that turns your crank.
 
Spend a little to upgrade scope and mounts (or dont, doesn't sound like you've had any issues) and start setting aside for something in the future. If you're new to the higher end rifle world you might splurge now, learn a whole lot, then wish you went a different route.

Worst comes to worst it sounds like you have a proven system already so you're not hurting to change anything (though I totally understand that's boring :) )
 
I really do like this rifle, and it has never let me down. It’s far more accurate than I can shoot, and has the three position safety very similar to the Winchester model 70’s that I first started hunting with when I was a teenager. Everything about action and barrel feels real solid.
You already have your answer.

My middle son killed a bull with his T/C Compass 6.5 Creedmoor with a Vortex Diamondback 3-10x50 four years ago. It's plenty accurate and will put stuff down.
 
I agree with others - get a stock you like and upgrade the scope. However, many of us own multiple rifles of all sorts.

If you were to add a 22-250, 22 creed or 204 Ruger for plinking/varmints it would get used quite a bit out west. A 17 HMR is also fantastic and much more accurate than a 22lr, but also get an accurate 22 lr. A 22 pistol is always fun to plink with while out and about or camping. I always have a 243 loaner rifle for anyone that needs it, that I also shoot the heck out of.

It’s a great time to keep an eye out for any cartridge that turns your crank.
I did indicate in my first post that the Creedmoor was my only rifle, but I already have the 204 Ruger, 17 HMR, 22 pistol and even a 243 loaner😃.

I really appreciate all of you chiming in, and find all of this very valuable wisdom. Being in an entirely new hunting field, I know I have a lot to learn.
 
Back
Top