Sitka Fanatic Sizing - L or XL?

[City Slicker]

Hoping to get some input on the Sikta Fanatic jacket, as I don't have a retailer nearby with a jacket in stock. I'm 6'2" 185-195lbs, thin build - 42" chest, 35.5" sleeve length. According to the Sitka size chart, I should order a large. However, I own a large tall in the Fanatic Hoodie, and it fits perfectly to my liking - still loose around the chest and long enough in the sleeve and torso. My main concern, since the Fanatic Jacket isn't in a large tall, is the torso length - as I prefer the longer length. Would a large be sufficient or should I size up to a XL? Appreciate any opinions!