Need some advice - Montana Rifle crapped the bed

RdRdrFan

WKR
Joined
Nov 19, 2015
Messages
651
So I've got two boys (6 & almost 2) and I've decided that I want to buy them each a rifle to give them when they turn 15 or 16. My plan has been to buy three identical rifles with consecutive serial numbers and put two of them away. I'd set mine up and we would all use it for the next several years. When they are of age, they would get their own gun just like mine.

So I've been thinking on the idea for a while but hadn't done anything about it. I thought I knew what I wanted. My plan was to buy 3 Montana Rifle Co. ASR's in consecutive serial numbers chambered in 6.5x284. I already own one in 260 and it's a definite shooter (less than 1/2 moa). So I look on their website and lay my eyes on the ALR. Beautiful gun. Basically an ASR with a higher grade wood stock. Only problem is that they only offer it in long actions and they show 6.5x284 as available only as a short action. No problem. A 6.5x284 can easily be run in a long action. So I call. First answer I get from Dean (guy I happened to get on the phone at Montana Rifle Co) is "nope we can't do that. It can't be done." I try to explain to him that I know that it "can" be done but I didn't know if they would do that. He told me that there was no way to run a 6.5x284 in a long action but finally agreed to check with their head gunsmith. Heard back today. They will do it but want a $200 upcharge per gun because it is a caliber they don't offer in the ALR and another $200 per gun "for the extra gunsmith work we will have to do to match the 6.5x284 barrel to the long action." I'm no genius but I wasn't born last night. I have no problem with a company making money.....at all. Hell, I was fully willing to pay full retail to the manufacturer for a gun that can regularly be bought through a dealer for several hundred under retail. But I'll be danged if I'll let em poke me in the eye for $1,200 extra above and beyond full retail for something that requires absolutely no extra work on their end.

So here is where I need help. I'm still wanting 3 rifles with consecutive serial numbers and I want them to be a classic look. Decent/good/great wood and blued. I want something that will shoot. I don't mind spending a bit of money but I'm not looking to totally break the bank either. I'd like to stay under $2,000 per gun (preferably well under that.....it's x3 after all).

What direction should I look? Cooper?
 
My cooper shoots great and they are nice people that greet you when you walk in their door.
 
Why not Winchester model 70's. If it's going to be there first rifle, or first nice rifle it's a hard one to beat. Is also suggest a more common caliber.....one that can readily be found in most stores.
 
What about a build? Buy three consecutive Montana actions and have a good smith put them together with barrels and stocks of your liking?
 
What about a build? Buy three consecutive Montana actions and have a good smith put them together with barrels and stocks of your liking?

Honestly, not too pleased with the way Montana chose to handle the situation so even if I went the build route I very likely wouldn't go with an action from them.

After doing some research on the Coopers I'm thinking of just buying two of them (one for each boy) and making them a bit nicer. Can someone please explain the differences in the Models at Cooper? I'm talking the model numbers not the names. Thinking of going with a Custom Classic and adding some options but I don't know what the difference is between a 22 and a 52.....or any of them for that matter.
 
Though not intimately familiar with Cooper, I'd look hard at Kimber (as others have stated) or Sako (though I'm not sure about the availability of the cartridge you seek).

Sent from my SPH-L710T using Tapatalk
 
I think Cooper is the best bang for your buck in the 'custom rifle' category.
 
Why not get a Montana ALR in an off the shelf caliber or an ASR in 6.5x.284? I don't think it is a fair assumption that what you are asking takes no extra work on their end.
 
Why not get a Montana ALR in an off the shelf caliber or an ASR in 6.5x.284? I don't think it is a fair assumption that what you are asking takes no extra work on their end.

ALR caliber offerings are too much recoil for a kid.

I was originally going with the ASR but I decided to go with nicer wood.

Either of those options would certainly save me some serious money over ordering what I want direct from Montana Rifle directly as I can purchase an in stock ALR or ASR from a dealer for $300-400 (per gun) under MSRP. I was willing to pay the retail price to Montana Rifle to get what I was wanting. But they wanted full retail PLUS $400 per rifle for something that doesn't require any additional work beyond how they enter the order in their system. At the end of the day it isn't worth it to me to pay $2,000-2,500 more to Montana Rifle when it doesn't take any additional work on their end. I was willing to pay $1,000-1,200 more (full retail) but I'm not going to get totally screwed. They were just trying to poke me in the eye. That's their call. But being greedy cost them some easy money.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top