Yes, I just read the 4 page threat on the opinions of a soft shell or not.
My take on it: for example - the first week of November in Colorado. You're hunting mule deer, hiking, moving around, glassing, could be thick vegetation. It's cold, but you're still moving around some. Could be some blowing snow and/or possibly a small snow storm. I don't think you want your puffy and rain jacket on at this time - it's going to be too warm for that and you'd spend half your day taking on and off layers. And I don't think you want a puffy alone. And I don't think you want a rain jacket alone. Soft shell is perfect here.