A super low budget choice would be the Eureka Solitaire. Not much fun to hang out in - but since they changed the poles from fiberglass to aluminum it's a decent option for sheltered locations considering the low price.
I prefer to be able to sit up in a shelter, so it's no longer one that I'd...
Stone Glacier krux evo and xcurve didn't work for me.
Mystery Ranch was pretty but after the changes in the harness sizing they made a couple of years ago their harnesses don't fit nearly as well me anymore. I considered grabbing an older Metcalf or similar pack before I ended up finding...
I'd encourage you to look at other options in addition to Seek Outside. There are several pyramid choices in that price range. A 9x9 or 10x10 from oware would work great. Dave might be able to sew a stove jack for you, or you could do it yourself or have someone else do it. I believe Argali has...
I would think 4 w/o a stove in the Redcliff would work fine if you guys are friends. Then again I'd do 4 in the Cimarron... as others have stated, a stove changes the equation. But IMO I wouldn't buy the 12 man unless I already had some places in mind where I wanted to set it up. It's too big...
Looks great. I did a bondo job on my ruger american rimfire stock and wondered how it would hold up - three years later with quite a bit of use and it's still holding up well.
Mora and Victorinox knives
Rick Young bino harness with lightweight binos
Casio digital watch
Chap stick
I'm not a big spender when I can avoid it. But I find that for reliability you usually have to go at least up into the mid-range of any type of product.
If you want to be safe and avoid any problematic crossovers you might have a hard time. The clock is ticking on Stone Glacier and Exo... it's only a matter of time. To be truly safe you need to buy from one of the real small, really uncool companies like Nimrod Packs.
FWIW I am bothered by...
Badlands, Kelty, Alps, etc... all very popular. I wonder how popular they are with people getting deep into the backcountry though. But I have no doubt people are getting it done with cheaper gear and older gear - I know they are.
Since there's not a choice for "other," I'll just leave a comment. My Outdoorsmans Optics Hunter is a great pack. The shoulder straps are very good. The hipbelt is pretty good - it's basically a wraparound style that has some similarities to Seek Outside and to older external frames. The frame...