I got a puncture in my Tensor like second night out. I was in a floorless shelter in a burn during a wind storm. It was one hell of a night. I believe a tarp stake pulled out but hung up in tarp loop. Said stake flopping in the wind and put hole in foot of pad.
I fixed hole with sealer and used...
If you bought through REI they have a great return policy. I used a trekking pole tent of theirs in the backcountry last year. Short story it did not work out for me. REI refunded me in full upon return.
Finished the season with my Big Agnes HV UL1. Other than being a little small it worked out...
The Big Agnes Copper Spur HV UL3 is a nice 3 person tent. I have personally carried it and spent a few night in it with the wife. The dual vestibule and doors are a must imo.
It seems to be very similar to the Quarter Dome you are looking at. Either would seem good to me.
Wish I grew up in a little logging town. Oh wait I did. It is now a big logging town. However, most people living there do not know it was a logging town.